What kind of device is that chart made for? cig-a-like? prebuilt coil? rda coil? Different devices need different powers
What kind of device is the chart designed for? Also goes with the above. If the device has a cutoff time for the fire button, the chart might not be usable if it assumes a 5 second warmup time or something like that.
Who's opinion is 'too hot' based on? Different people feel differently. Different people like different temps.
How much vapor is the chart designed to help you produce? Maybe the vapor your producing following the chart is what the chart was designed to produce.
What kind of liquid is the chart designed for? Maybe it was designed for VG juices and your using a PG juice, or vice versa.
How much power time is the chart assuming? Maybe your just not holding the fire button long enough, maybe the chart assumes a warmup time and not instant production. I can get vapor off a 20 gauge 0.14 ohm coil @ 20 watts, but I need to hold the fire button down for 10 seconds for it to warm up first.
What kind of gauge wire is it based around? This is probably the biggest thing. Thicker wire = longer heat up time before vapor production, or more power needed to heat it up just as fast as thinner wire. A 1.2 ohm coil made out of 26 gauge kanthal will need more power then a 1.2 ohm coil made out of 36 gauge kanthal to reach the same level of heat in the same amount of time (hence the power time mentioned above). The 26 gauge kanthal can also support higher wattages then the 36 gauge kanthal due to being a thicker wire. Might even need these higher watts to produce the same temp vape as the 36 due to being a larger wire.
According to that chart, I was running my nautiluses 'too hot' when I was using 12 watts.
Most charges aren't scientifically proven documents, they are just based around the personal experiences and opinions of one or more people.