the fat tail was it cake batter and creamit was a little overpowering for my taste very heavy on the cake batter not very heavy on the cream and it had a weird smell the SJ milk shared the same weird smell and I got the strawberry right off the bat but again the cream was lacking the smell that it was putting off also came through in the taste not sure if it was something that they're using but it was just off putting for my taste I'm letting it steep and going to try it again in a couple weeks